Model Files
The study package for inspecting, modifying, and running the NIST 4-story pure SMF model contains the files below.
Package Contents:
NIST_4Story_SMF_3D.vfodb— the 384-element VFO Pro model file with ASCE 41 RBS beam hinges and coupled P-M-M column hinges.Northridge_CanyonCountry_LOS270.txt&LOS000.txt— the ground-motion acceleration records (in units of g, 0.01 s time step).
1. Archetype Overview & Benchmark Purpose
This benchmark study provides a complete modeling, configuration, and analysis walkthrough for the NIST Technical Note 1863-1 4-Story Special Moment Frame (SMF) archetype in VFO Pro. The building is modeled as a full 3D Pure Special Moment Frame structure in both orthogonal building directions ( and ), capturing concentrated beam plasticity, multi-axial column interaction, and second-order geometric effects.
National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) Technical Note 1863-1 evaluates first-generation performance-based seismic design procedures (ASCE/SEI 41-06 and ASCE/SEI 41-13) against standard archetype steel buildings designed in accordance with ASCE/SEI 7-10. This 4-story archetype represents a typical commercial office building situated in a high-seismicity region in Los Angeles, California.
| Reference Publication | Assessment of First Generation Performance-Based Seismic Design Methods for New Steel Buildings, Volume 1: Special Moment Frames (NIST TN 1863-1, Feb 2015) |
| Authors & DOI | John L. Harris III and Matthew S. Speicher · doi:10.6028/NIST.TN.1863-1 |
| Building Archetype | 4-Story Steel Office Building, Risk Category II (), Seismic Design Category (Los Angeles, CA) |
| Footprint & Height | ( per floor), Total Height (, ) |
| Framing System | 3D Pure Special Moment Frame (SMF): 3 bays in (Grids 1 & 6), 3 bays in (Grids A & F), gravity framing elsewhere |
| Material Specification | ASTM A992 Grade 50 Steel (, Expected , ) |
| Seismic Demand | BSE-1 (, ), represented by the Northridge Canyon Country record pair scaled by 1.396 |
| Reported Analyses | 6-mode eigenvalue analysis, nonlinear gravity (Dead + 0.25 Live), bidirectional nonlinear dynamic time history at BSE-1 |
2. NIST Report Reference & Building Geometry
The archetype layout reflects modern California commercial steel framing with composite metal deck floor diaphragms. In NIST TN 1863-1 Section 2.1, two standard design variations are presented: an Equivalent Lateral Force (ELF) design and a Response Spectrum Analysis (RSA) design. This study implements the ELF member schedule.
Click to zoom
The building footprint spans 150 ft along the longitudinal () axis across 5 equal 30 ft bays (Grids A through F), and 100 ft along the transverse () axis across 5 equal 20 ft bays (Grids 1 through 6). Floor elevations are established at 18 ft (Level 2), 32 ft (Level 3), 46 ft (Level 4), and 60 ft (Roof).
Click to zoom
In the longitudinal () direction, lateral resistance is provided by two identical 3-bay perimeter moment frames on Grid Lines 1 and 6, spanning between Grids B, C, D, and E (90 ft frame length). Column sections step down at the 3rd floor (elevation 32 ft). Beam connections feature Reduced Beam Sections (RBS) designed per AISC 358-10 to force flexural plastic hinging away from the column face.
3. Core Modeling Assumptions: Transition to Pure SMF
An essential structural distinction in this study is the transition from the original mixed SFRS to a Pure Special Moment Frame system in both principal directions.
In the original NIST TN 1863-1 building design, the longitudinal direction () was designed as an SMF, while the transverse direction () was designed as a single-bay Special Concentrically Braced Frame (SCBF) located between Grids 2 and 3 on Grids A and F.
Click to zoom
Engineering Rationale for the Pure SMF Configuration
When conducting advanced nonlinear dynamic response history analysis (NDRHA) under severe bidirectional seismic records (e.g. maximum considered earthquake shaking), the single-bay chevron braced frame introduces significant modeling challenges:
- Severe Axial Force Concentration: With only a single 20 ft bay resisting all transverse lateral shear, brace axial forces reach extreme levels, generating large overturning tensile uplifts and compressive loads in the adjacent columns.
- Brace Buckling & Fracture Sensitivity: Under traditional phenomenological brace formulations, cyclic buckling and tension rupture create sudden stiffness drops that induce numerical convergence stalls during intense ground motion peaks.
- Pure Moment Frame Benchmark: Replicating the 3-bay moment frame architecture on Grids A and F (spanning Bays 2–5) creates an ideal, purely ductile dual-axis benchmark building. This allows structural engineers to rigorously study 3D multi-axial column yielding () and beam plastic hinge behavior under bidirectional excitation without brace fracture anomalies.
The transverse SMFs on Grids A and F span three 20 ft bays between Grids 2, 3, 4, and 5 (total frame length = 60 ft). The columns in these transverse frames are rotated with localAxes = 90, ensuring that their strong flexural axis ( in VFO Pro) is aligned directly with the global seismic demands.
Grid A Grid B Grid C Grid D Grid E Grid F
Grid 6 O=============+=============+=============+=============+=============O (100')
(North) | | [======== 3-Bay SMF Frame 1 (X) =======] | |
| | | |
Grid 5 #=============+-------------+-------------+-------------+-------------# (80')
| 3-Bay | | 3-Bay |
Grid 4 # SMF (Y) | | SMF (Y) # (60')
| Frame 3 | | Frame 4 |
Grid 3 # (West) | | (East) # (40')
| | | |
Grid 2 #=============+-------------+-------------+-------------+-------------# (20')
| | | |
Grid 1 O=============+=============+=============+=============+=============O (0')
(South) | | [======== 3-Bay SMF Frame 2 (X) =======] | |
0' 30' 60' 90' 120' 150' (X)
Legend:
[====] Special Moment Frame (SMF) with RBS Beams & Fixed/Coupled PMM Columns
[----] Gravity Framing with Pinned Beam Connections (m3 released)
O Corner Gravity Columns (W14x90, Base Pinned)
# SMF Y-Columns (W14x257/233 int, W14x159/145 ext, localAxes = 90, Base Fixed In-Plane)
+ Interior Gravity Columns (W14x90, Base Pinned)
4. Member Schedules, Section Properties & RBS Geometry
The structural members are modeled from standard AISC Wide-Flange cross sections using ASTM A992 Grade 50 steel with expected yield strength () per ASCE 41-13 Table 9-1.
4.1 Beam Schedule & Reduced Beam Section (RBS) Parameters
Beam sections vary across the height to match the ASCE 7-10 Equivalent Lateral Force design:
| Story Level | Elevation | Beam Section | Cut (in) | Length (in) | Depth (in) | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Roof | 60’-0” (720”) | W24×55 | 3.75 | 16.0 | 1.75 | 0.741 |
| 4th Floor | 46’-0” (552”) | W24×76 | 4.50 | 16.0 | 2.25 | 0.741 |
| 3rd Floor | 32’-0” (384”) | W24×84 | 4.75 | 16.0 | 2.25 | 0.763 |
| 2nd Floor | 18’-0” (216”) | W24×84 | 4.75 | 16.0 | 2.25 | 0.763 |
4.2 Column Schedules
SMF column sections change at the 3rd floor level (elevation 32 ft): the lower two stories use the heavier shapes. Splice details are not modeled.
| Location | Stories 1 & 2 (Elev 0’–32’) | Stories 3 & 4 (Elev 32’–60’) | Base Boundary Condition | Column Local Axis |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| SMF Interior Columns | W14×257 | W14×233 | Fixed in-plane (ux, uy, uz and in-plane rotation) | Lines 1 & 6: 0° · Grids A & F: 90° |
| SMF Exterior Columns | W14×159 | W14×145 | Fixed in-plane (ux, uy, uz and in-plane rotation) | Lines 1 & 6: 0° · Grids A & F: 90° |
| Gravity Columns (corner & interior, 20 total) | W14×90 | W14×90 | Pinned (ux, uy, uz = 1) | 0° |
4.3 Gravity Members & Moment Releases
The building contains 192 gravity beam elements (96 along and 96 along ). All -direction gravity beams are W16x26; along , 80 are W27x84 girders and 16 are W16x26. All gravity beams have major-axis moment releases assigned at both ends (releases: { i: { m3: true }, j: { m3: true } }), accurately representing standard shear-tab web connections and ensuring zero unintended moment transfer into gravity columns.
5. Nonlinear Constitutive Modeling in VFO Pro
VFO Pro implements concentrated plasticity for both frame beams and columns, providing numerically stable performance-based assessments conforming to ASCE 41-13.
5.1 Beam Moment-Rotation Plastic Hinges
Beam elements are modeled using OpenSees concentrated plasticity via beamIntegration('ConcentratedPlasticity'). Each RBS hinge is defined by a yield moment and five backbone points given as scale factors of . is the expected plastic moment at the center of the reduced beam section, with and , where is the RBS cut depth (NIST TN 1863-1, Appendix C gives and for the W24×84). The rotation parameters follow ASCE 41: (0.0428 rad for , as in Appendix C), and a residual strength ratio .
| Point | Moment | Rotation (rad) |
|---|---|---|
| 1 (yield) | 0.001 | |
| 2 | ||
| 3 | ||
| 4 | ||
| 5 |
| Hinge | (in³) | (in) | (in³) | (kip-in) | (rad) | (rad) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
mhW24x84_rbs | 224 | 2.25 | 143.2 | 7,874 | 0.0428 | 0.0513 |
mhW24x76_rbs | 200 | 2.25 | 129.0 | 7,092 | 0.0428 | 0.0514 |
mhW24x55_rbs | 134 | 1.75 | 93.2 | 5,125 | 0.0429 | 0.0515 |
The limit states (IO, LS, CP) are set to , and .
The first backbone point sits at 0.001 rad, so the hinge has a finite initial rotational stiffness ( for the W24×84, several times the beam's own end rotational stiffness ). Between points 1 and 2 the backbone keeps a post-yield stiffness of about (about 4% of the initial stiffness). The residual branch (points 4–5) is flat.
5.2 Column Coupled P-M-M Hinges (ASDCoupledHinge3D)
SMF columns undergo concurrent axial force and bidirectional bending demands. In VFO Pro, column hinges are implemented using the ASDCoupledHinge3D component via Frame Compound Components (zeroLengthSection elements) at the top and bottom of each column lift:
- Fully models 3D yield surface interaction across axial force () and biaxial moments () per AISC 360-16.
- Captures softening, cyclic degradation, and axial shortening under high axial compression.
- Backbone: after yielding, the strength hardens to 1.05 times the yield strength (a hardening ratio of 1.05) at the plastic rotation , and then softens toward the residual strength () at . The limit states are 0.01, 0.02 and 0.03 rad.
- Initial Flexural Stiffness Calibration: In zero-length compound hinges, an excessively stiff elastic rotational penalty () creates severe matrix ill-conditioning. VFO Pro calibrates the yield rotation floor to (), eliminating ill-conditioning while preserving true elastic drift and yield thresholds.
6. Step-by-Step VFO Pro Modeling Workflow
The following step-by-step procedure walks through building and analyzing the 3D pure SMF model in the VFO Pro graphical interface:
-
Project Setup, Grid System & Story Elevations
Set project units to
kip-in-sec(). Under Grids, define Cartesian lines: and . Under Stories, define Base (), L02 (), L03 (), L04 (), and Roof (). -
Materials & AISC Sections
Under Define › Materials, create
A992_Grade50with , , and . Under Sections, import the required shapes: columns (W14x257,W14x233,W14x159,W14x145,W14x90) and beams (W24x84,W24x76,W24x55,W27x84,W16x26). -
Define Nonlinear Hinge Properties
Under Define › Frame Hinges, configure the moment-rotation hinges for beams and coupled P-M-M hinges for columns:
Click to zoom
Figure 6-1: Defining the ASCE 41 moment-rotation beam hinge mhW24x84_rbs: yield moment , moment scale factors (0.66, 0.95, 1, 0.5, 0.5) and the rotations of points 2–5. -
Assign Compound Component Column Hinges & Beam Integration
Select the SMF columns and open Assign › Frame › Hinges. Select Frame Compound Component and assign
ASDCoupledHinge3D(e.g.pmmCol_W14x257) at column ends. For SMF beams, select Beam Integration and assignconcentrated-plasticity-beam-integrationwith the respective RBS hinge.
Click to zoom
Figure 6-2: Assigning multi-axial coupled column hinges ( pmmCol_W14x257) and section integration properties in VFO Pro. -
Assign Gravity Loads & Visual Confirmation
Assign distributed line loads to the floor beams under the
Deadload pattern (self-weight is included in the pattern). Use Display › Display Loads to confirm the assigned loads in the viewport.
Click to zoom
Figure 6-3: Display Loads view of the Deadframe line loads on all four floors in VFO Pro. The labels show between and , depending on tributary width. -
Boundary Conditions, Diaphragms & Lumped Masses
Restrain the 16 SMF column bases (Grids B–E on Lines 1 & 6; Lines 2–5 on Grids A & F) against translation (
ux, uy, uz = 1) and against rotation in the plane of their frame (ry = 1for the columns of the frames along ,rx = 1for the columns of the frames along ). This follows NIST TN 1863-1, where the column bases of the lateral system are rotationally restrained in the plane of the frame and unrestrained out of plane. Assign translational pins (ux, uy, uz = 1,rx, ry, rz = 0) to the 20 gravity column bases. Apply rigid floor diaphragms (autoFloorDiaphragm) and the floor seismic masses as nodal masses (NIST TN 1863-1 seismic weights: Roof 1,095 kips, 4th floor 1,345 kips, 3rd floor 1,359 kips, 2nd floor 1,377 kips; 5,176 kips in total).
Click to zoom
Figure 6-4: Complete 3D model view of the 4-story pure SMF showing column base supports, diaphragm master nodes, and perimeter moment frames. -
Configure Analysis Load Cases
Under Define › Loads › Cases, define the cases used in this study:
- Modal: 6 modes using the
genBandArpackeigenvalue solver. - Dead: Nonlinear static gravity case (20 load steps) combining the
Deadpattern with 0.25 of theLivepattern. - Northridge_BSE1: Bidirectional nonlinear dynamic time-history case starting from
Dead(, 2000 steps, Rayleigh damping of 2.5% at modes 1 and 2). Acceleration data:LOS270along andLOS000along , each with scale factor 1.396.
The model file also contains
Pushover_X,Pushover_YandNorthridge_BSE2cases. They are not part of this study.
Click to zoom
Figure 6-5: VFO Pro Load Case Definition for Northridge_BSE1nonlinear dynamic time-history analysis with 2,000 output steps at . - Modal: 6 modes using the
7. Simulation Results
This study reports the modal response and the bidirectional Northridge_BSE1 time-history response of the pure SMF model.
7.1 Modal Periods, Frequencies & Mode Shapes
The eigenvalue analysis returns the first six modes of the 3D model:
| Mode | Period (s) | Frequency (Hz) | Dominant Direction | Effective Modal Mass (%) | Description |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mode 1 | 1.709 | 0.585 | Longitudinal () | 87.8 | 1st translational mode in |
| Mode 2 | 1.568 | 0.638 | Transverse () | 89.1 | 1st translational mode in |
| Mode 3 | 1.102 | 0.908 | Torsion () | — | 1st torsional mode |
| Mode 4 | 0.489 | 2.044 | Longitudinal () | 9.7 | 2nd translational mode in |
| Mode 5 | 0.474 | 2.108 | Transverse () | 8.6 | 2nd translational mode in |
| Mode 6 | 0.341 | 2.929 | Torsion () | — | 2nd torsional mode |
Click to zoom
Click to zoom
Modes 1 and 2 are clean translational modes in and , carrying about 88% and 89% of the effective modal mass. The first torsional mode () has a period about 64% of the fundamental period, so it is well separated from the two translational modes.
7.2 Nonlinear Dynamic Time-History Response (BSE-1)
The model was subjected to bidirectional excitation from the 1994 Northridge, Canyon Country – WLC station record pair (FEMA P-695 record set, NIST TN 1863-1 Table A-1). Component LOS270 acts along and LOS000 along , each scaled by 1.396 for the BSE-1 hazard level. Each record has 1,999 points at 0.01 s (about 20 s), and the analysis starts from the gravity state of the Dead case.
| Story | Elevation (in) | Peak IDR (%) | Peak IDR (%) | Residual IDR (%) | Residual IDR (%) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Story 4 (Roof) | 552 to 720 | 1.28 | 1.98 | 0.04 | 0.56 |
| Story 3 | 384 to 552 | 1.36 | 1.99 | 0.02 | 0.59 |
| Story 2 | 216 to 384 | 1.48 | 2.07 | 0.08 | 0.66 |
| Story 1 | 0 to 216 | 1.37 | 1.88 | 0.07 | 0.71 |
Interstory drift ratios (IDR) are computed from the displacements of the IDR node stack defined in the model. Residual values are taken at the end of the record (). Drift is spread fairly evenly over the height, with story peaks of 1.28–1.48% in and 1.88–2.07% in . The largest values are 1.48% in (story 2, at ) and 2.07% in (story 2, at ). Residual drift is below 0.1% in and 0.56–0.71% in . The and peaks occur at different times because the two ground-motion components peak at different moments.
All 96 beam hinge ends yield, and 51 exceed the IO limit ( rad). Only one end exceeds the LS and CP limits: element 351 (W24×76, 4th floor, Grid F), end I, reaches 0.067 rad at , beyond the end of its backbone ( rad). At that instant the two column hinges at the same joint also rotate by about 0.08 rad within about 0.05 s. The next largest beam hinge rotation is 0.0238 rad (element 356, end I). Among the column hinges, 15 of 128 exceed 0.01 rad. Figure 7-3 shows the most demanding second-floor beam hinge, element 267 end J, which peaks at 0.0168 rad (), between the IO and LS limits.
Click to zoom
mhW24x84_rbs) under Northridge_BSE1, plotted against the ASCE 41 limit states (IO, LS, CP). The marker is at (, , between IO and LS); the 3D view shows the deformed frame with hinge states at that step.
Click to zoom
Northridge_BSE1. Each curve is the drift profile at the instant of the largest drift in that direction ( at , at ).8. Analysis Settings Used for BSE-1
The Northridge_BSE1 case uses the following settings, all visible in the case form under Define › Loads › Cases:
8.1 Damping
Rayleigh damping of 2.5% of critical is specified at modes 1 and 2. The mass- and stiffness-proportional coefficients are computed from the periods of those two modes at the start of the case.
8.2 Integration & Solution Parameters
| Setting | Value |
|---|---|
| Initial condition | Dead (gravity state) |
| Time step / output steps | / 2000 |
| Integrator | Newmark, average acceleration (, ) |
| Algorithm | Modified Newton |
| Convergence test | Energy increment, tolerance , up to 1000 iterations |
| Equation solver / numberer | UmfPack / RCM |
| Constraint handler | Transformation (rigid floor diaphragms) |
| Geometric nonlinearity | on all columns |
Last updated November 12, 2026 · applies to vfopro 20261107.0.0 or later